It’s cocoa season, and some of the best marshmallows on the market are these hand-cut numbers from 240 Sweets. Made in small batches by two women in Columbus, Indiana, they are incredibly fluffy, never too sweet, and delicately flavored. This Neapolitan trio includes vanilla bean, dark chocolate, and “Hoosier strawberry”—and we’d be hard-pressed to pick a favorite.

Here’s what you get:
- Three bags of flavored marshmallows (3 per bag, about 1.75" x 1.75" each)
- Flavors include: vanilla bean, dark chocolate, strawberry